Valta ja rikosoikeudellinen vastuu: tuomioistuinten toimivalta käsitellä valtiojohdon tekemiä kansainvälisiä rikoksia

Translated title of the contribution: Power and criminal liability - jurisdiction of courts over international crimes committed by state leaders

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

There are several instances where state leadership can be held criminally liable for international core crimes. In terms of national courts, state leaders can be tried either in their home state or another state. International alternatives include the International Criminal Court, an ad hoc criminal tribunal, a hybrid tribunal or a so-called internationalised tribunal. The jurisdictional basis of each court rests either in customary law or international arrangements, depending on the court concerned. Each alternative has its pros and cons. The home state typically has numerous jurisdictional bases over crimes perpetrated by its leaders, but its capacity is restricted by politics and the leadership’s constitutional privileges. Trials in home states are also subject to bias. Other states, while being able to ground their jurisdiction in the universality principle, must consider the immunity of foreign state leaders. The significance of international tribunals has greatly risen since the 1990s, but establishing jurisdiction and securing arrests remain major concerns. International procedures are also often delayed and continue to face challenges based on the principle of legality. The issues noted in the article emphasize that international criminal law is not an effective way to influence present conflicts, and that discussions on criminal liability pertaining to present conflicts are bound to remain speculative
Translated title of the contributionPower and criminal liability - jurisdiction of courts over international crimes committed by state leaders
Original languageFinnish
Pages (from-to)652–679
Number of pages28
JournalLakimies
Volume121
Issue number5
Publication statusPublished - 4 Oct 2023
MoEC publication typeA1 Journal article-refereed

Keywords

  • international criminal law
  • international criminal court
  • criminal law
  • criminal jurisdiction
  • heads of state
  • state leaders
  • war crimes
  • Ukraine
  • jurisdiction

Field of science

  • Law

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Power and criminal liability - jurisdiction of courts over international crimes committed by state leaders: tuomioistuinten toimivalta käsitellä valtiojohdon tekemiä kansainvälisiä rikoksia'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Citation for this output